← All New Mexico categories

Top 100 Insurance Companies in New Mexico — Graded

157 insurance companies in New Mexico clear our data floor — verified in at least two independent sources with a working phone or website — and are graded by one published formula. The top 100 are below; the full ranked list is split by area. Grades refreshed monthly; data current as of 2026-10-25.

Albuquerque Metro (72)Las Cruces (15)Rest of New Mexico (59)Santa Fe (11)
1
97AI ScoreTop 1%
April Garcia Insurance Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
2
97AI ScoreTop 2%
Barbara Fort Insurance Agency Inc
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
3
97AI ScoreTop 2%
Dominic Vigil Agency
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
4
97AI ScoreTop 3%
Farmers Insurance
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
5
95AI ScoreTop 4%
Perfection Insurance Services
Rio Rancho · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
6
95AI ScoreTop 4%
The Mosimann Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
7
95AI ScoreTop 5%
Tracy Idinopulos
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action97
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
8
93AI ScoreTop 6%
State Farm
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
9
91AI ScoreTop 6%
Art Sandoval - State Farm Insurance Agent
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action87
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
10
91AI ScoreTop 7%
Mike Guerin - State Farm Insurance Agent
Hobbs · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action90
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
11
88AI ScoreTop 8%
Allstate
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
12
83AI ScoreTop 8%
State Farm
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
13
83AI ScoreTop 9%
State Farm
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
14
83AI ScoreTop 9%
StateFarm
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
15
81AI ScoreTop 10%
Leavitt Group SW Insurance
Truth or Consequences · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action70
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
16
80AI ScoreTop 11%
Allstate
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy73
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
17
80AI ScoreTop 11%
Allstate
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy73
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
18
80AI ScoreTop 12%
Allstate
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy73
Online action85
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
19
80AI ScoreTop 13%
Farmers Insurance - Thomas Gutierrez
Taos · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action70
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
20
80AI ScoreTop 13%
Farmers Insurance Alicia Lucero
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action70
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
21
80AI ScoreTop 14%
Perry Conner
Artesia · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action70
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
22
75AI ScoreTop 15%
State Farm
Gallup · Website
Legitimacy76
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
23
75AI ScoreTop 15%
State Farm
Bernalillo · Website
Legitimacy76
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
24
75AI ScoreTop 16%
State Farm Insurance
Carlsbad · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action60
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
25
75AI ScoreTop 16%
State Farm Insurance
Artesia · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action60
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
26
75AI ScoreTop 17%
State Farm Insurance
Los Lunas · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action60
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
27
74AI ScoreTop 18%
State Farm
Rio Rancho · Website
Legitimacy73
Online action75
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
28
73AI ScoreTop 18%
Associated Insurance Professionals
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
29
73AI ScoreTop 19%
Rio Grande Insurance Services
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy97
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
30
73AI ScoreTop 20%
Sturtevant & Associates Llc
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy76
Online action70
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
31
73AI ScoreTop 20%
Alcorn Insurance Agency
Chama · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
32
73AI ScoreTop 21%
Angela Romero Insurance Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
33
73AI ScoreTop 22%
Clay Fultz Insurance Agency
Gallup · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
34
73AI ScoreTop 22%
Tusker Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
35
73AI ScoreTop 23%
Villar Insurance Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
36
71AI ScoreTop 23%
Auto Insurance Plus
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
37
71AI ScoreTop 24%
Axcess Insurance
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
38
71AI ScoreTop 25%
C and R Insurance
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
39
71AI ScoreTop 25%
Daniels Insurance Agency
Hobbs · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
40
71AI ScoreTop 26%
Daniels Insurance Inc
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
41
71AI ScoreTop 27%
Farmers Insurance
Rio Rancho · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
42
71AI ScoreTop 27%
Farmers Insurance - Cathy Muse
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
43
71AI ScoreTop 28%
Freedom Insurance
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
44
71AI ScoreTop 29%
J S Ward and Son
Artesia · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
45
71AI ScoreTop 29%
Pebsworth Insurance
Portales · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
46
71AI ScoreTop 30%
RAC Insurance Services
Hobbs · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
47
71AI ScoreTop 30%
Roberts and Associates
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
48
71AI ScoreTop 31%
USA Insurance Inc
Alamogordo · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
49
71AI ScoreTop 32%
Walker Agency
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
50
71AI ScoreTop 32%
Western States Insurance Group
Clovis · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action55
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
51
70AI ScoreTop 33%
All Star Public Adjusters
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
52
70AI ScoreTop 34%
Bonnie Ornelas - State Farm
Carlsbad · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
53
70AI ScoreTop 34%
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
54
70AI ScoreTop 35%
Farm Bureau Financial Services
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
55
70AI ScoreTop 36%
Farmers Insurance Darin Manes
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
56
70AI ScoreTop 36%
Garcia Insurance LLC
Portales · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
57
70AI ScoreTop 37%
George Gandy Insurance
Artesia · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
58
70AI ScoreTop 37%
Grindell & Romero Insurance
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
59
70AI ScoreTop 38%
Randy Castillo Insurance Agency PC
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
60
70AI ScoreTop 39%
State Farm Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
61
70AI ScoreTop 39%
Sunset Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
62
70AI ScoreTop 40%
The Health Insurance Store
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
63
70AI ScoreTop 41%
Western States Insurance Group
Lovington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action52
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
64
69AI ScoreTop 41%
Tom Blanchard Insurance
Silver City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
65
69AI ScoreTop 42%
Ultimate Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
66
69AI ScoreTop 43%
Wesky Insurance Inc
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
67
68AI ScoreTop 43%
Eric I. Maestas Insurance Agency
Farmington · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
68
68AI ScoreTop 44%
Red Rock Insurance Agency
Gallup · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
69
68AI ScoreTop 44%
Tabet Insurance Agency
Belen · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action49
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
70
67AI ScoreTop 45%
Lopez Insurance Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy76
Online action60
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
71
67AI ScoreTop 46%
State Farm
Roswell · Website
Legitimacy76
Online action60
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
72
64AI ScoreTop 46%
Jennifer Johnson State Farm Agent
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
73
63AI ScoreTop 47%
Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Mexico
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
74
63AI ScoreTop 48%
Fidelity National Title of New Mexico
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
75
63AI ScoreTop 48%
Fred Loya Insurance
Rio Rancho · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
76
63AI ScoreTop 49%
Leavell Insurance Inc
Hobbs · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
77
63AI ScoreTop 50%
Orale Insurance Agency
Santa Fe · Website
Legitimacy93
Online action40
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
78
57AI ScoreTop 50%
Agsure, Inc.
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
79
57AI ScoreTop 51%
Golden Insurance Agency Pc
Artesia · Website
Legitimacy100
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
80
57AI ScoreTop 51%
Garnett Insurance Agency
Logan
Legitimacy96
Online action27
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
81
55AI ScoreTop 52%
A.w. Pollard Insurance Agency Inc
Deming · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
82
55AI ScoreTop 53%
Advanced American Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
83
55AI ScoreTop 53%
Advanced Brokerage Services
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
84
55AI ScoreTop 54%
All-star Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
85
55AI ScoreTop 55%
Alpha Nurses
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
86
55AI ScoreTop 55%
Axcess Financial Group
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
87
55AI ScoreTop 56%
Berger Briggs Insurance & Risk Solutions
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
88
55AI ScoreTop 57%
Bernal Insurance Group
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
89
55AI ScoreTop 57%
Burba, Cole & Overstreet
Carlsbad · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
90
55AI ScoreTop 58%
Capital Aspects
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
91
55AI ScoreTop 58%
Client First Llc
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
92
55AI ScoreTop 59%
Covell Consultants
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
93
55AI ScoreTop 60%
Fred Loya Insurance
Clovis · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
94
55AI ScoreTop 60%
Insurance First
Silver City · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
95
55AI ScoreTop 61%
Insurance Unlimited
Las Cruces · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
96
55AI ScoreTop 62%
Integrity Insurance
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
97
55AI ScoreTop 62%
Jackson Insurance Solutions
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
98
55AI ScoreTop 63%
Jerry Smith & Associates
Rio Rancho · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
99
55AI ScoreTop 64%
M & M Insurance Agency
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking
100
55AI ScoreTop 64%
Market Finders, Inc.
Albuquerque · Website
Legitimacy96
Online action25
Reviewsno data yet
Coverage 35% · 2026-10-25
Claim this ranking

See every graded insurance company: Albuquerque Metro · Las Cruces · Rest of New Mexico · Santa Fe

How the AI Score works

Every company carries an AI Score from 1–100, computed by one published formula from the signals measurable today — legitimacy and online action, verified across at least two independent sources (open place datasets and public registries). The formula's other factors — blended reviews, complaint record, and responsiveness — carry no weight in the score until licensed data sources for them exist. When they land, the score re-spreads across the full formula.

One disclosed exception: a score of 100 is reserved for RankMyCompany clients; every other score is computed by the same formula for everyone. Scores are not spread artificially — companies with identical measured data share identical scores — and each listing also shows its rank and its percentile within its category.

Missing-data rule: when a factor has no lawful data source for a company yet, its weight redistributes proportionally across the factors that do have data, and every score shows its data-coverage %. Coverage rises as licensed sources are added; scores are recomputed monthly and score history is kept for every company.

No score is ever adjusted by hand, sold, or removed for payment. Companies marked RMC Client are scored by the exact same formula as everyone else — the 100 cap above is the only exception, and it is disclosed here rather than hidden. If your company's underlying data is wrong, file a correction on the dispute page — disputes fix the data, and the corrected data flows into the next ranking run.

Place data: © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL) and Overture Maps Foundation (CDLA Permissive 2.0). Listings are refreshed monthly; a score change from a refresh takes effect only after the new score holds for two consecutive runs. Formula changes are published as a new methodology version — never applied silently.

Read the full standard — The RMC Standard →